If you’re here, you already know something about your website isn’t working. Maybe inquiries are slow, you’re getting the wrong people into your offers, or (the worst) people keep telling you they “love your work!” but don’t actually end up hiring you.
Copy is the FIRST place you should be looking. The words on your website are what’s going to get someone to go from “I like her” to “I’m hiring her!”
Now, the hard part is figuring out exactly what about your website copy needs to change.
As a website copywriter who specializes in writing websites that sell (so service providers can stop relying on referrals) I can usually tell within 1 minute of landing on someone’s site why it isn’t converting.
Here’s exactly what I look for, what you shouldn’t try because it doesn’t work, and the exact process I’d use to fix your website if it’s not converting.
(And btw? no, the answer isn’t more traffic. If your site isn’t converting the people already landing on it, sending more people there is just going to get you more people leaving.)
Why your website isn’t converting (probably)
Nine times out of ten, the problem lies in a lack of specificity. Your copy isn’t specific enough about
- Who you help
- What problem you solve,
- How they feel about that problem
- What they’ve already tried
- How you solve their problem
- The key result you deliver
- Why you’re perfectly qualified to deliver it
I could go on.
A lack of specificity on one of these things is sloppy. A lack of specificity on all of these things and you’re basically paying for a fancy billboard for your business. (Just telling people you exist, but not much more.)
The frustrating thing is that your copy might sound fine, but it gives your reader nothing to attach to emotionally, so there’s nothing driving them to inquire.
Let’s dig into this more so you can see how this problem might be showing up for you:
You’re describing what you DO, but not what clients hire you to ACHIEVE
Most service providers describe their service by saying “I do social media” or “I do graphic design” or “I do home improvement.”
But nobody is hiring you for the deliverable. They’re hiring you for the problem it solves or the desire behind it, and that’s the part most business owners have a really hard time putting into words.
Here’s the tricky part: in their heads, nobody doubts that you’re talented, good at your job, and worth the money — you’re just not worth the money to them.
Shifting the copy to talk about what you help people ACHIEVE, not just what you do for them is how you help them go from “here’s an option” to “I want exactly what I can achieve with this person.”
You’re talking to too broad an audience
What I’ve found is that clients are on board with this one in theory, but when push comes to shove, they still get uncomfortable with speaking to fewer people in their copy. Speaking to a broader audience feels safe, but it often backfires.
People browsing your site are looking for something that feels pretty damn near personalized to their problem. The broader you go, the weaker every line on the page gets.
The goal is copy so specific that you’re about to be accused of mind reading. (And if you’re not actually listening to your clients to see what resonates with them, you better start!)
You’re handing them a Cheesecake Factory menu of results
Let’s say you’re a graphic designer or social media manager. Your work probably gets results across a dozen different categories (brand recognition, elevated perception, increased visibility, conversions, etc.) It likely does more for your clients than even you realize.
But listing every result you could theoretically deliver is like handing someone the Cheesecake Factory menu and expecting them to instantly know what they want. It’s overwhelming, and will likely fall deaf ears.
Instead, focus on one result that would really make a difference and that you can confidently deliver.
Maybe it’s consistency. Maybe it’s conversions. Maybe it’s doubling their social media views within two months. Whatever you could reliably place in front of your dream client and they’d go “yes! I want that!”
The more specific your promise, the easier it is to say yes to.
You’re not giving them a reason to act now
And hear me when I say, I do not endorse your use of fake countdown timers or “only 2 spots left!” when that isn’t true. Please don’t do that.
Good urgency comes from naming what’s keeping the reader stuck and what they’re choosing to give up by staying there.
Every month they don’t solve this, what is it costing them? Time? Money? Sanity? The clients they actually want?
When your copy makes the cost of waiting clear, inquiring stops feeling like a big leap and starts feeling like the obvious next step.
What people usually try first to fix their website’s conversions (that doesn’t work)
And just in case you’re thinking of trying any of these things, let me give you a warning: they don’t work.
- Copying the competitor you’re most jealous of: That competitor has their own strategy, perspective and expertise. You won’t steal their clients by copying them, you’ll just look like a lesser version of what they’re doing.
- Throwing every testimonial you’ve ever gotten on the page: Testimonials and case studies are important, but they’re not a replacement for good copy. Big chunks of wordy feedback and random videos need to be used strategically, not dumped on the page.
- Lowering your prices: If your copy isn’t showing your value, discounting it won’t fix anything.
- Creating a new offer: Again, I wouldn’t assume your offer is the problem until you’ve fixed the copy, especially if you have good results and a good track record.
*Exactly* how I fix websites that aren’t converting
Now, you know I’m not just going to judge your copy and then say “trust me bro” while sending you an invoice to fix it. My process has three stages: 1) signal mining, 2) conversion mapping and 3) translation. Here’s what each one looks like in practice.
Step 1: Signal Mining – finding what moves people to buy
I start by digging through everything a client already has. Testimonials, their onboarding questionnaire, any messaging or marketing homework they’ve done, emails, sales call transcripts, DMs, comment sections, etc.
I’m looking for buyer signals: the things that will shift the reader’s beliefs on the page. Sometimes these signals are straightforward, like a case study showing the exact result your reader is hoping for.
Sometimes the signals are more covert, for example: perhaps you have a track record of working with business owners who have ADHD. A reader with ADHD is going to feel supported signing on with you, and that’s worth putting on the page, even if it doesn’t *technically* have anything to do with your work.
The best copy gems are usually things my clients say offhand. Little throwaway comments that show their genius perspective on their work, or what their clients say about them when they aren’t even in the room.
Most business owners can’t spot these on their own. They’re so deep in the trenches of their niche that getting into the shoes of a first-time visitor is a muscle they’ve never learned to flex.
I have. I know how to pick up on those gems, and I know where to put them once I’ve got them.
Step 2: Conversion Mapping – presenting information in the order they need to hear it
All your competitors have “nice words” on their websites. That’s not why people buy.
They buy when the copy takes them through what they need to believe first, second, third, etc. until they realize that investing in your service is safer for them than staying stuck where they are.
So I’ve pulled your buyer signals, I map them in the order they need to be presented in for someone to convert. This is essentially the outline of your website.
Step 3: Translation – writing it all in language they’re already using
Then I draft the copy in your ideal buyers’ own language. Not jargon, buzzwords, or whatever sounds most impressive.
I use the words your clients actually use when they describe their problem. I use the very things your best clients have said to their friends in order to refer your to them. The things they’re thinking, but don’t know how to find the words to say. (This is where the mind-reading accusations come from haha.)
BTW, I also handle the SEO and the handoff to your designer, so the copy shows up on the page the way it’s meant to and gets seen by people who are already looking for it.
Case Study: Simpler copy for selling $15K packages
I wrote the website copy for an exceptional designer and marketer whose outdated site wasn’t positioning her anywhere near as good as she actually was.
Her clients (local and brick-and-mortar businesses) weren’t super tech literate. They weren’t going to master AI tools or keep up with what was trending on social media. They just wanted their marketing handled efficiently, in a way that got them results, by someone who really knew their stuff when it came to marketing for brick-and-mortar businesses and local SEO.
So we didn’t try to make her sound like a digital girl boss — we focused on how easy she made it to hire her.
On her biggest package, she took care of everything: the website, social media, SEO and design. Her clients just provided input and answered the questions she needed from them. Nobody had to get techy or overthink their brand messaging.
We also leaned into her personality. She’s laid-back and has no desire to overcomplicate things, and none of that means sacrificing quality.
The result was copy that spoke to the problems her clients were actually dealing with and made her services feel like the easy, intuitive solution. No bells and whistles that sound impressive on the page but fall on deaf ears with her audience.
Her packages now go up to $15K, and selling them is pretty easy for her. That’s the power of good copy on your website.
What if your website converts, but brings in the wrong clients?
Sometimes the most frustrating thing about a website that is underperforming isn’t that you’re getting no people, it’s that you’re getting the wrong people (which, if you’re a service provider, you know this is often worse because they take up time that could be spent on dream clients.
When a client comes to me with this problem, I often find myself asking two questions. Who are the wrong clients? And who looks good on paper but isn’t great to work with in actuality?
If you’re attracting clients that aren’t fun to work with
Sometimes it’s a values alignment thing. If your copy is corporate and stuffy, you might be getting a lot of corporate and stuffy people into your offers. Not ideal! I, personally, would never!
This fix is fun because it will involve changing your tone of voice or speaking to different values.
(Fun example: there is a reason why I talk about Taylor Swift and Sabrina Carpenter in my copy: they’re qualifying people who are essentially a good culture fit for Dark Roast Copy Co. It’s fun, but it’s also strategic.)
If you’re attracting clients who push back on your prices
Maybe clients push back on your prices. Or maybe they pay, but act resentful or flighty when the invoice comes.
That usually comes down to positioning, and to what you don’t say as much as what you do. Skip the “here’s what it’s worth to hire me” justifications and the “if that’s too much, here’s a smaller package” alternatives here.
The simple fix is to assume your reader has the budget. Write to the people who are going to see your prices as a no-brainer.
Quick answers to common questions
Why is my website getting traffic but not converting?
Traffic and conversions are two separate problems. If people land on your site and leave, your copy isn’t giving them a specific enough reason to stay and inquire.
You could also be targeting SEO keywords that don’t exactly match what a potential buyer would be searching for. I handle SEO in my copywriting packages as well, so this is something we can look at during your project too.
How do I know what to fix first so my site will convert better?
Honestly, this is a blog post. I can’t see your website or know what you’re talking about.
If you’re a service provider who produces good work and has great testimonials though, I’m pretty damn sure the copy should be your priority.
I’d recommend reaching out to an expert (hi!) if you don’t want to waste time though, and just want it to be fixed.
Will a redesign fix my conversions?
Good question! Good website design is very important, but it primarily addresses brand perception and user experience. Your copy still needs to be good if you want it to convert better.
If the words aren’t specific, a redesign will just make the same generic message prettier.
Want to know exactly why your website isn’t converting?
If you read this and recognized your own site, I can help you fix it. My Website in a Week is the signature offer I recommend to most new clients of mine. It’s the best way to go if you want to fix your conversion problems quickly and effectively (while still retaining your voice and unique flare.)
Reach out here to start your website copy project, and let’s turn your website into something that gets people absolutely hyped to work with you from.
